Sunday, July 4, 2010

Help me decide on a woodworking signature!

In the olden days, craftsmen would often "sign" their work with a coin set flush in the wood. The coin would bear the date of the year in which the work was made.

I think this is a wonderful idea, and decided to start doing it myself, so I ordered a special Forstner bit in the size of a United States quarter. But for my first such "signature," I thought I'd set a coin in my shaving horse, which is, to date, my favorite woodworking project. However, when I went through my spare change bucket looking for a quarter from 2007 (the year I built the horse), I found that the two state quarters minted that year were Wyoming and Montana. Now, Montana's design is pretty nice, but honestly, Wyoming's leaves something to be desired...

An unembellished bronco rider? Really, Wyoming? This is all you could come up with?



Compare this to Montana:

Very nice, in a rugged Georgia O'Keefe kind of way.

While I was going through the quarters, I also found the ones for Texas:



...and New Mexico:

...the two states to which I claim spiritual (and actual) citizenship, having lived in one or the other for all of my life, and I got to thinking that maybe I should use one of those instead, even though they bear the wrong dates. After all, the notion of laying claim to Home Ground is writ large in my life, and using a coin from one of these two states says something about me.

So here are the choices:

On the plus side for signing with the proper date coin: Well, it's the proper date.

On the minus side: They aren't that exciting to look at and/or I have no real connection to the states.

On the plus side with going for one of my two "Home Ground" states: I am all about spiritual connection to place.

On the minus side: The New Mexico and Texas coins have the wrong date.

Making a choice about this affects the direction I go with future signatures, in that whichever I go with, I should probably be consistent and use the same template from now on. So, as you see, this is a heavy decision to make--which is why I am allowing you to weigh in on it!

So help me out by going to the poll widget on the sidebar and casting your vote. I reserve the right to make the final decision, but I'd like to hear your opinions on the matter. Thanks a bunch, and cast away!

15 comments:

  1. You are too funny, and yes, Wyoming's quarter is lame-o.~~Dee

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, Wyoming has that whole amusing hipster irony thing going for it ("The Equality State?" Really? Yes, they let women vote first, but when the most recent "equality" thing you've done is almost 100 years old, it's time to find a new slogan, no? New Jersey, I'm looking at you too.), and I actually don't think the image is that terrible. I mean, it may not be you, but in and of itself, it's not terrible. I think, of the four, I like Montana's best. And I'm almost positive there are bleached animal skulls in Texas and New Mexico. So I'd say go with that.

    Are we committed to the idea of using a quarter? 'Cause there are other coins, where the date would be correct, and, unless you go with a dollar coin: hey, cheap.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't know how your mint handles it, but is there no way to hang in till you find a coin with the right date, right state? That's the way I'd go. (But, actually, I don't mind Wyoming's coin; I like the clean, simple lines.)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dee--can't wait to meet you in Buffa10!

    MrS--I like the Montana one, too; plus, I had my one and only successful fly-fishing experience there...

    Helen--Nope, can't do it. These are special issue quarters, minted in specific years. Hence, the dilemma. And I like clean lines, too, but I think Wyoming has simply gone too far.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Heh. I LIKE Wyoming's quarter, because I think of rodeos and wild horses when I think of what very little I know of that state. But I think that you should simply go with your instincts and pick the one that first spoke to you.

    ReplyDelete
  6. First, I have to say I think this is a really great idea.

    Really a shame that the TX coin wasn't minted in the correct year. Or, that you didn't build your shaving horse in the correct year :-D. Since it is the year that is important here I vote for Montana.

    Lastly - I need to ask a "stupid" question. Just what do you use a "shaving horse" for?

    Lindy in AZ

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Dr. T!

    I voted for the Texas/New Mexico one, but I would personally go for the New Mexico quarter. Dates would be cool, but I think the images the quarters have stands out more than the numbers.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think you should look under the sofa cushions, there may be something there more to your liking.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I like Washington. Right date, a big fish and mountains!

    Beg for one. I am sure someone will send you one.

    ReplyDelete
  10. "Plain" quarters come in every date and have ornithological superiority over TX, NM, WY, or MT. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Jodi--I think that is probably what I'm going to do. I just need validation. ;-)

    Lindy--Not a stupid question at all. A shaving horse is a special bench used for some kinds of carving. I use mine to carve canoe paddles.

    Laura--Hey back atcha! I'll take your vote under advisement.

    Les--Sound advice.

    Carmella--I'll see if I can scrounge one up and take a look-see.

    Nancy--Ha! Nice try. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Instead of having to choose betweens tate quarters, why not use a nickel? They're all the same so no state/place favoritism and in future projects they'll look more consistent.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ten years on down the road, what is going to bring the deepest smile to your soul -- the correct date, or something that speaks the prairie woman in you? I voted for the “Home Ground”!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ten years on down the road, what is going to bring the deepest smile to your soul -- the correct date, or something that speaks the prairie woman in you? I voted for the “Home Ground”!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well, because I have such a connection to Texas and I long to be back there, I'd go with Texas. But that's my reason, not yours. Although it is kind of close to yours, i.e., the spiritual aspect of your decision. I do like the looks of the Montana one.

    Hope to meet you while in Buffalo. Won't be long now!

    ReplyDelete